Photo credit: Hughes Léglise-Bataille
As Boris makes a splash racing to arm police with controversial water cannon, Katie Marston and Jacob Mignano investigate why locals are sceptical.
“The police were stood there all dressed up in riot gear, and did nothing.”
Almost three years on from riots which scarred the country, Cyprian Asota still rails against the perceived impotence of police in preventing the violence. The proprietor of Boots opticians, Mare Street, watched on as youths ransacked his 35-year-old business.
Convinced by poll results, the Mayor of London has thrown his support behind the Metropolitan Police’s controversial call for water cannon. Two-thirds of the 4,223 people consulted agreed that water cannon should have a limited role in tackling the “most serious public disorder”, and more than half said they would feel more secure with the proposed measures.
But despite Boris Johnson directly linking his support for water cannon to the riots in a letter to the Home Secretary, those hardest hit in August 2011 by the riots are among the harshest critics.
Mr Asota does not feel it should ever have gone this far. “Would water cannon make any difference? No. If police actually said to them ‘boys, can you stop what you’re doing?’ they would have stopped. It wouldn’t have even escalated. If they used water cannon my shop would have been flooded.”
Siva Kandiah watched on television as his convenience shop on Clarence Road was pillaged by rioters. He drove to his shop, only to find his way blocked by police.
“Police pushed them onto Clarence Road trying to protect the high street, then they stepped back. So I asked officers: ‘Why are you just standing and looking?’ The riot police – not even normal police – were doing nothing. They said they didn’t have the authority.”
When asked whether water cannon would have had any impact, Mr Kandiah wavers. “It might do,” he says. “More people would be scared. Sometimes you have to do things to control people, to control rioters. Not legal demonstrations, that would be wrong, but riots have to be controlled.”
Only 13 per cent of people believe that a water cannon would make them less confident about police ability to respond to serious disorder. Hackneyites who witnessed the carnage are more opposed.
Yvonne Howard, 58, from Stamford Hill, sees the issues as going deeper than police tactics. “What would make me feel safe is if people didn’t live in such poverty and had meaningful opportunities.”
Political opposition
Precedents have been set from Turkey to Paris, often resulting in injury or even maiming of student protesters. But would what works on the streets of Istanbul bring security to the people of Hackney?
Jennette Arnold, Greater London Authority member for Hackney, says the Mayor “has been badly advised. The arguments in favour of water cannon are totally bogus. During the riots, the horrific scenes we saw across London were partly a result of the Met not being effective and decisive enough.
“Water cannons are unwieldy and slow and would not be effective when people change location to wrong-foot the police. Policing by fear, rather than policing by consent, will not work.”
If Theresa May, the Home Secretary, grants a licence for the water cannon, three German machines will be modified for use on the capital’s streets, at a cost of up to £300,000.
The Met, who petitioned for the water cannon, state that they strongly believe it is a tactic that will help them “keep the peace and keep Londoners safe”, although they intend for it to be “rarely seen and rarely used”.
That, argues Ms Arnold, is another problem altogether, particularly given the mayoral elections.
“We could end up with a different Mayor who wants to get rid of the cannon. This would result in hundreds of thousands of pounds being spent for no reason.”
As barbs are fired back and forth about the validity of the consultation, the Police Action Centre has called for a judicial review of the Mayor’s decision.
Theresa May refused to fund the water cannon, so the measure would need to be paid for by the London authorities.
Diane Abbott, MP for Hackney North and Stoke Newington, calls the move “weaponising”.
“The use of water cannon would be largely symbolic,” she wrote in The Guardian. “But the symbol would be a truly horrific one for anyone who believes in the long-term importance of policing by consent.”
Meg Hillier, MP for Hackney South and Shoreditch, fears water cannon could lead such situations to escalate. “I have met the Met Police to discuss their deployment. It is fairly clear that they would not have been easily deployed on the night of the riots in Hackney,” she says.
“Three available machines would have been spread thin in August 2011.”
Related articles:
